Skip to main content

Bill Simmons' proposed Giannis-Jazz trade begs important question

Antetokounmpo would vault the Jazz into contender status, but Utah would have to give up a lot.
Jan 27, 2025; Salt Lake City, Utah, USA;  Milwaukee Bucks forward Giannis Antetokounmpo (34) keeps the ball away from Utah Jazz forward Lauri Markkanen (23) during the second half at Delta Center. Mandatory Credit: Chris Nicoll-Imagn Images
Jan 27, 2025; Salt Lake City, Utah, USA; Milwaukee Bucks forward Giannis Antetokounmpo (34) keeps the ball away from Utah Jazz forward Lauri Markkanen (23) during the second half at Delta Center. Mandatory Credit: Chris Nicoll-Imagn Images | Chris Nicoll-Imagn Images

Among the most inexplicable plotlines in the NBA right now is Giannis Antetokounmpo is still on the Milwaukee Bucks for some reason. It had become clear as day this season that it was time for both sides to move on, and yet they're still together.

It's like The Simpsons. It ran its course, but just let it end already. It would be hard to see how Antetokounmpo would like to keep this union going after such a disastrous season combined with him now being in his 30s. If a trade is on the horizon, the Utah Jazz would have a pretty solid deal to offer.

Granted, they gave up their best draft assets when they acquired Jaren Jackson Jr., but they still have All-Star players now and exciting young talent to develop. Bill Simmons floated the idea of sending Antetokounmpo to Utah on his podcast.

"The one team I wouldn't rule out for Giannis, which we did not mention: the Utah Jazz," Simmons said. "Because I think they are at the 'f--- it stage' of all of this. Like, they just basically rolled over for the past couple of years..."

"And they have Markkanen, and they have Ace Bailey... But, my assumption would be that maybe [Jaren Jackson Jr.] is part of the trade. Or maybe Markkanen is a part of the trade. One of those two guys with a lot of their picks, and they just try to talk Giannis into Salt Lake, basically."

A possible Antetokounmpo trade has been brought up multiple times over the past two years. He's still one of the NBA's best players, and depending on what Utah would send over, he would vault them to inarguably one of the NBA's biggest threats.

But there comes a question worth pondering.

Is a Giannis trade really worth it for the Jazz at this point?

From a talent perspective, most definitely. However, a real problem that has emerged over the past few years is his health. Antetokounmpo's ultra-physical style of play, which, mind you, is why he's been one of the NBA's most dominant forces in league history.

However, his style is also starting to catch up with him, as he missed Milwaukee's playoff run in 2024 due to a calf injury, missed a good chunk of last year's season due to injury, and has played roughly half the season because of recurring injuries. This has all the makings of someone whose body clearly won't hold up the way it used to.

Simmons actually brought that up while discussing a potential Giannis-Jazz trade.

"What am I giving up for Giannis at this point?" Simmons asked. "How many minor to semi-minor leg injuries can a guy have and be in their early 30s with a lot of miles and games in them, where I start to get worried somebody's trying to sell me a car that they rolled back the odometer on?"

The uncertainty would only get stronger if a trade were to be done, as Antetokounmpo may have two years left on his deal, but it's very likely he'll opt out to fetch a more expensive long-term one. Would he want to stay in Utah? And would Utah be willing to trade all that much for a flight risk?

Antetokounmpo is a better talent than Markkanen, JJJ, and Bailey, but is his star talent at this point really worth giving up two of the three with his injury problems for the past few years? Especially if he's a flight risk?

The Jazz are in great position already as is, and acquiring Antetokounmpo isn't the easy choice it would have been at this time a year ago. It would be exciting to bring him in, as it would signal that Utah's not messing around

Loading recommendations... Please wait while we load personalized content recommendations